by Bill Onasch
Instead of the promised continued look at worker productivity I am centering this WIR on more time sensitive issues–set in historical context. In the process this became the longest WIR to date.
Still Not In Business For Our Health
Open enrollment through the exchanges created by the Affordable Care Act begins Tuesday for English speakers–maybe. The Spanish language website for sure won’t be up for another few weeks. Initially, visitors to exchange sites in many states may find they are not yet completely functional, lacking such key information as services provided and premiums charged.
Essentially, every U.S. resident not already covered by employer offered health insurance, or the public Medicare, Medicaid, or Veterans Administration programs, must go to the exchanges and buy private health insurance. Those with low income may be eligible for government credits and subsidies to help pay premiums. Any choosing to remain uninsured are liable for hefty fines.
The important health sector of the ruling class, despite the occasional kvetch, are pleased. They should be–they wrote the law and the rules for implementing it. If all goes as planned, they will have millions of new customers.
Paradoxically, the traditional favorite party of Big Business is fighting like the Japanese garrison on Iwo Jima to stop or cripple this bonanza for the insurance robber barons. Perhaps even more bizarre, our labor statespersons have assumed the role of Marines aiming to triumphantly raise the flag of ObamaCare on Mount Suribachi.
If the mean spirited cracked teapots were to succeed in killing or maiming ObamaCare, with no alternative readily available at this late stage, it would be bad news for millions of uninsured individuals and unions who have been bargaining with employers in anticipation of major changes in insurance.
For these reasons opposing the loony right sabotage is an understandable reflex. But I have been bombarded by appeals from labor, women’s, and civil rights groups to not only denounce Republican kamikazes but to also hail the Affordable Care Act as the greatest thing since sliced bagels.
Such a position is merely the flip side of the teapot opportunist coin. Both camps subordinate the health of American workers to the perceived short term political needs of a boss party.
The Affordable Care Act does not resolve America’s health care crisis. In many ways it makes things worse. The unexpectedly low premiums touted by the President and Secretary Sebelius last week do not take in to account the extremely high deductibles and copays that accompany these “bargains” in affordable care. The cheapest plans would require spending thousands of dollars out of pocket before insurance starts paying sixty percent of further costs.
The best alternative to commodity health care that is expanded by the new law would be socialized medicine such as the British Labor Party established in that country 65 years ago. That hasn’t gained much traction yet in the USA.
The less comprehensive but still significant and worthwhile single-payer reform–an improved version of Canada’s Medicare won by the NDP labor party north of the border–has. In all the pre-ObamaCare polls in which single-payer was included as an option it consistently received the most support.
At the 2009 AFL-CIO Pittsburgh convention the California Nurses Association (now part of National Nurses United) took the initiative in organizing delegates to support a fight for single-payer in the health care debate beginning in Congress. Michael Moore, who helped popularize single-payer in his 2007film SiCKO, moved the world premier of his film Capitalism A Love Story to a theater near the convention site and the Nurses organized a pro-single-payer march of hundreds of delegates to the showing. These efforts succeeded in adding support for a single-payer bill, with an impressive list of sponsors, already introduced by Rep John Conyers from Detroit, to the Federation’s health care program . Out of these achievements in Pittsburgh the Labor Campaign for Single-Payer was launched.
Senator Max Baucus was charged by the White House to get ObamaCare through Congress. To assist him a senior health insurance industry official came to do her bit at public service on his Finance Committee staff by drafting the Affordable Care Act and later fleshing out its implementation. In hearings she was always by Baucus’s side.
When Baucus refused to allow testimony from single-payer advocates some of them made a mild but vocal protest of their exclusion. He had them arrested and jailed for contempt of Congress.
Newly elected AFL-CIO president Richard Trumka tried very hard to be a “player” in the long struggle to get a health care bill through Congress. He immediately jettisoned single-payer and eventually even the symbolic “public option.” In the end, he did his duty for his White House friend through heavy-handed lobbying to get single-payer supporters–whose votes were sorely needed–on board for ObamaCare. The bill would have never passed without Trumka’s diligent efforts.
Since then both the AFL and Change to Win unions have tried to justify their cave-in by being the most energetic and exaggerating apologists for their “friend’s” signature achievement. While single-payer still remains an official position of record, at the recent AFL convention in Los Angeles its advocates had to be content with a literature table in the lobby.
But even at that carefully choreographed conclave discontent with the Affordable Care Act still erupted. Many were livid over the surprise exclusion of multi-employer health care plans negotiated by unions from credits and subsidies available to all other plans. This is a mortal threat to the very existence of these plans. A resolution demanding a fix was passed and a delegation headed by Trumka was dispatched to meet with the President.
But their “friend” in the White House–who had earlier granted reprieves from some provisions of the new law to employers without even being asked–condescendingly explained he could not tinker with the law of the land as a favor to friends.
With a degree of loyalty usually only seen in abused pets, our mainstream union officials continue to do the heavy lifting for their pal in the White House, his party–and, in this example, the insurance company moguls.
ObamaCare will likely survive the current Republican assault even if it’s pushed to a government shutdown. But this is no victory to crow about from our side. We’ll still be saddled with a substandard health care system devouring a far bigger share of our GDP than any other country.
On October 11, the Labor Campaign for Single-Payer will be holding a special Expanded Steering Committee and Advisory Board Meeting in suburban St Louis to take stock of where that movement is at and where to go over the next year. They are inviting all single-payer supporters to attend. You can find details by clicking here.
Beginning that same evening in the same place is a unique weekend conference, Jerry Tucker: The Person, The Mission, The Legacy. The conference website says,
“For more than 30 years, Jerry Tucker was an inspiring figure of the labor movement. His untimely passing in October 2012 was mourned by many in the labor community and beyond. Over the years, Jerry was a rank-and-file worker, union leader and adviser, and mentor to many. This conference explores Jerry’s work within the labor movement and examines the fundamental question that he wrestled with throughout his long career: How do we build a powerful social movement and exercise the collective might of the working class through true solidarity, accountability and democracy? We will discuss how to apply Jerry’s vision to today’s struggles, and we will celebrate his extraordinary life through music, videos and personal testimony.”
Even though it is a challenge for a Social Security pensioner’s budget, I wouldn’t miss this tribute to a principled working class fighter I held in highest esteem. I hope to see many WIR readers there as well.
The first opportunity I had for an extended discussion with Jerry was at a Labor Party Advocates gathering in St Louis that called the 1996 Labor Party Founding Convention. I hope that the need for revival of the labor party project will be a part of the conference discussions. It should be crystal clear that we will not resolve health care or any of the other crises facing the American working class until we have a party of our own.
GE Zaps More UE Workers
One of the strategic targets for elimination as part of the restructuring of the U.S. Economy mentioned in last week’s WIR is a union in which I was deeply involved back in the day–the United Electrical, Radio & Machine Workers (UE). Since the 1980s, the UE national agreement with General Electric has been systematically battered by plant closings, reducing representation to a handful of surviving sites.
A few months ago, GE announced plans to move hundreds of jobs from its Erie, Pennsylvania Locomotive Works–one of its biggest remaining North American plants, organized by UE–to a recently opened facility in Ft Worth, Texas. Now they have targeted the UE plant in Ft Edward, New York. In an e-mail message Chris Townsend, the UE’s “Capitol Hill Shop Steward,” writes,
Some of you may already be aware that the General Electric Company (GE) has announced their intention to close and abandon the Ft. Edward, New York capacitor plant after more than 70 years of profitable production. This plant is notorious as it is one of two plants that polluted both the Hudson Falls and Ft. Edward communities, along with an enormous stretch of the Hudson River. The largest geographic Superfund site in the country is a mess made by GE’s
dumping of toxic chemicals, oils, and PCB’s into the community and the Hudson River for several decades. After furiously resisting governmental efforts to take responsibility for years on end, GE was ultimately forced to fund the clean up of the river and numerous polluted areas in the region. That cleanup is ongoing and will take decades more to complete.
While these electrical capacitor plants once employed several thousand workers, in recent years GE has refused to invest in new equipment or machinery and the workforce has been reduced to just over 200. Even under these conditions the GE plant in Ft. Edward remains one of the best places to work in the entire region. Workers earn living wages, most still retain a real pension, and Local 332 ensures that GE honor the terms of the UE-GE national labor contract. UE has for many decades worked tirelessly to ensure that the immediate and long term health and safety of the workforce and retirees is not ignored….
This week I was in Ft. Edward and the UE Local 332 membership unanimously endorsed an aggressive campaign to force GE to maintain capacitor production in Ft. Edward.
As this struggle unfolds you will be able to access update bulletins directly by visiting the main UE web page; http://www.ueunion.org/
Much of the coming campaign will be a simple test of whether elected leaders and regulators at all levels will confront the brazen and destructive behaviors of GE. The UE membership intends to do so. On behalf of the Local 332 members and their families, thanks very much for taking a look.
United Electrical Workers Union (UE)
As always, there were many more other stories this past week deserving of comment than can be included in a column of manageable size–even this record breaking one. One story we will soon follow up on is the latest report on climate change by UN scientists. Links to articles of interest are posted on our companion Labor Advocate Blog, updated by 9AM Central, Monday-Friday.
A reminder in closing, as I must mention once in a while, we have no other revenue sources to support travel and other expenses than contributions from readers. If you appreciate the Week In Review, and haven’t recently sent us anything, now would be a good time. You can click on to our Donate Page for options to use PayPal or a credit card or–our preference–send a check or money order.
That’s all for this week.